3872 Erie Street, Willoughby, OH 44094 - Lake County

Built in 1888, this 7,500± SF three-story brick building is a preserved piece of Willoughby’s industrial history, offering unmatched charm, character, and versatility. Originally a flour mill, it has been carefully restored to maintain its original wood floors, industrial design, and functional adaptability, including a first-floor overhead door for easy access. The building also features a newer roof, adding to its structural integrity and longevity. The fenced-in yard provides flexible outdoor space for events, storage, or operational needs, while adjacent paved parking with leased space from Norfolk Southern Railroad ensures convenient accessibility.

With its historical significance and distinctive atmosphere, the property is perfectly suited for a boutique hotel, microbrewery, distillery, event venue, or cultural attraction. Its rich history and paranormal reputation make it a natural draw for ghost tours, historical programming, and tourism experiences, further enhancing its appeal. This rare and authentic property presents endless possibilities, blending preserved industrial charm with modern potential, making it an unparalleled opportunity to create something truly special in Downtown Willoughby.

Financials available with NDA

Copyright © 2025 MLS Now. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.