405 Second Ave, Monte Vista, CO 81144 - Rio Grande County

Step into this beautifully restored Victorian gem and become part of Monte Vista's living history. Originally built in 1910 by Andrew and Louisa Van Nostrand-German immigrants who arrived from Iowa in the early 1900s-this stately home has been a cornerstone of the community for over a century. Andrew, a prominent landowner, cattle baron, and county commissioner, played a pivotal role in developing the region's irrigation waterways that still nourish our farmlands today. The Van Nostrands family called this home until 1921, and all rest in Monte Vista's cemetery alongside their son and daughter-in-law. Subsequent owners left their mark on both the property and the town. The Welty family cared for the home for more than 30 years, followed by Ed Sharp in the 1950s-best known for helping to establish the Wolf Creek Ski Area and as a fixture of the local funeral business. In the 1970s, Dr. John McDaniels, a Harvard-educated professor and beloved philanthropist at Adams State College. Dr. McDaniels was a history professor and a John F. Kennedy fanatic and worked on the Kennedy administration. He lived in the home for five decades until his passing in 2023. When Bill and Bernadette Hagendorf purchased the property from the McDaniels Estate in October of 2023, they found over 40,000 books throughout the home. The Hagendorfs have meticulously refurbished the property to preserve its original woodwork and Victorian allure. This home isn't just a place to live; it's a testament to Monte Vista's rich tapestry, awaiting the next chapter of its extraordinary story. Exterior Highlights • Situated on approximately 1/2 acre (5 town lots) , framed by eight grand blue spruce trees • Original two-story carriage house with newly added French doors • Greenhouse with automatic roof vent, fully fenced gardens, sidewalks, and mature lawn • Large wraparound porch with wicker swing for soaking up summer evenings • Heated, finished single-car garage via concrete drive • Updated freestanding outdoor brick grill/pizza oven • Newly repointed brick exterior and fresh paint on original wood trim • New sewer line installed May 2022 First Floor Interior • Newly refinished hardwood floors and restored quarter-sawn oak trim • Period-correct paint colors and two original mantled fireplaces-one with antique Victorian iron front, the other with an efficient wood-burning insert • Formal dining room with original oak paneling and iconic William Morris "The Strawberry Thief" wallpaper • Butler's pantry featuring antique shelves and cupboards • Spacious bathroom with tiled handicap-accessible shower, free-standing slipper tub, William Morris floral wallpaper, marble-top antique vanity with dual sinks, separate toilet room, and period tile flooring • Completely remodeled English-style kitchen: gas stove with custom vent hood, fluted-front farm sink, custom cabinetry with soft-close doors, new white quartz countertops, and more William Morris wallpaper • Adjoining mudroom with custom-built bench seating Second Floor Interior • Four bedrooms, each with a walk-in closet, new texturing/paint, high-end plush carpet with pet-proof memory foam padding, and period light fixtures • Large bathroom with laundry facilities, new marble-top double vanity, and custom glass-block windows Third Floor Interior • Spacious bonus area with two built-in desks, white wood walls, hardwood flooring, oversized closet, and an adjoining walk-in storage • Newly remodeled bathroom featuring a shower and stylish barn door Throughout the Home • Entire electrical system replaced and brought to 2023 code, including new meter loop, service entrance, and hardwired smoke detectors • 2" wood blinds • Original doors with working skeleton keys This is far more than a residence; it's a living piece of Monte Vista's story, ready for you to author its next chapter. Don't miss the chance to call this Victorian treasure at 405 Second Avenue your own.

Copyright © 2025 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.